Saturday, September 30, 2006

Evolution and God   posted by lol @ 9/30/2006 04:20:00 PM
StumbleUpon Toolbar Digg Reddit Del.icio.us Ma.gnolia Newsvine

GSS SCITEST4 asks
In your opinion, how true is this? ... D. Human beings developed from earlier species of animals.

Frequency Distribution
Cells contain:
-Column percent
-N of cases
HUMANS EVOLVED FROM ANIMALS
1
DEFINITELY TRUE
2
PROBABLY TRUE
3
PROBABLY NOT TRUE
4
DEFINITELY NOT TRUE
ROW
TOTAL
GOD1: DONT BELIEVE9.3
51
2.3
26
2.0
12
1.0
12
2.9
101
2: NO WAY TO FIND OUT9.5
52
5.6
63
2.9
17
.4
5
3.9
137
3: SOME HIGHER POWER18.6
102
13.7
155
5.2
31
1.8
22
8.8
310
4: BELIEVE SOMETIMES5.5
30
5.8
66
3.0
18
.9
11
3.5
125
5: BELIEVE BUT DOUBTS19.5
107
21.8
246
22.2
132
5.7
71
15.8
556
6: KNOW GOD EXISTS37.7
207
50.8
574
64.7
385
90.4
1,133
65.2
2,299
COL TOTAL100.0
549
100.0
1,130
100.0
595
100.0
1,254
100.0
3,528



Color coding:<-2.0<-1.0<0.0>0.0>1.0>2.0Z
N in each cell:Smaller than expectedLarger than expected


As you would expect, this also holds for BIBLE:

Frequency Distribution
Cells contain:
-Column percent
-N of cases
SCITEST4
1
DEFINITELY TRUE
2
PROBABLY TRUE
3
PROBABLY NOT TRUE
4
DEFINITELY NOT TRUE
ROW
TOTAL
BIBLE1: WORD OF GOD14.0
47
21.0
160
31.6
134
54.5
466
34.0
807
2: INSPIRED WORD44.9
151
56.7
432
54.7
232
41.5
355
49.2
1,170
3: BOOK OF FABLES39.6
133
21.7
165
12.5
53
3.3
28
15.9
379
4: OTHER1.5
5
.7
5
1.2
5
.7
6
.9
21
COL TOTAL100.0
336
100.0
762
100.0
424
100.0
855
100.0
2,377


The trend holds when you compare across groups by educational attainment. Here is a table of the average response to SCITEST4 (lower = better).

Main Statistics
Cells contain:
-Means
-N of cases
DEGREE
0
LT HIGH SCHOOL
1
HIGH SCHOOL
2
JUNIOR COLLEGE
3
BACHELOR
4
GRADUATE
ROW
TOTAL
GOD1: DONT BELIEVE2.71
14
1.87
47
2.33
3
1.32
25
1.75
12
1.85
101
2: NO WAY TO FIND OUT2.36
14
1.93
55
1.25
4
1.69
36
1.56
27
1.82
136
3: SOME HIGHER POWER2.12
33
2.13
146
1.88
17
1.62
81
1.41
32
1.91
309
4: BELIEVE SOMETIMES2.37
19
2.17
66
2.14
7
1.94
18
1.47
15
2.08
125
5: BELIEVE BUT DOUBTS2.52
62
2.40
292
2.56
36
2.06
108
1.88
58
2.30
556
6: KNOW GOD EXISTS3.06
414
3.20
1,251
3.07
146
2.82
344
2.38
132
3.06
2,287
COL TOTAL2.89
556
2.88
1,857
2.81
213
2.37
612
2.00
276
2.72
3,514


Color coding:<-2.0<-1.0<0.0>0.0>1.0>2.0T
Mean in each cell:Smaller than averageLarger than average