Friday, November 08, 2002
I am no longer a warblogger.
The term has changed its meaning, and the change has left me on the outside. I realized this some weeks ago, and my decision was further vindicated by more evidence that Tom Coates is a reasonable guy:
Coates, if you did not know, is the guy whose offhand remark started the "most bloodthirsty warblog" contest, which I've commented on before here and here. It seems to me that Coates is the reasonable guy in this little fracas - and I'm nothing if not a partisan of the "reasonable guy" position. In fact, this whole contest issue has pushed me to a decision I was edging towards anyway: the repudiation of the "warblogger" title. I used to half embrace this term as denoting "someone who blogged about war and was not a pacifist", but now the term has been hijacked by extremists to mean "those who support an all-out war on Islam and/or the Middle East". I've always believed that it's the duty of those who consider themselves centrists to criticize extremists on the merits of their position - or else risk being associated with them. I'm not talking about the "rhetorical distancing" tactic (ably described by Sailer) in which one excoriates an ideological kinsman as "extreme" while subscribing to a position with nary an epsilon of difference from the "extremist's" own views. Rather, I refer to a detailed point-by-point listing of what's wrong with extreme warblogging and why it's not the hard-nosed, pragmatic, and realistic philosophy that its advocates believe it to be. So in the next few days (or weeks, or whenever I get around to it), I'm going to post a more in-depth analysis of what the warblogger movement was and what it has become. A few quick points as prequel: 1) It's easy to score points and look smart when your opponents are the caliber of WarbloggerWatch. Those who opposed action in Afghanistan because "war is bad for children and living things" are sitting ducks, and need only be pushed a little bit to collapse under the weight of their inconsistency. [1] Many of the self-proclaimed centrists (yes, I consider myself a centrist - perhaps a radical centrist) were unaware of the extreme positions of some bloggers because many of their heavily linked posts were devoted to refuting similarly extreme opponents on the other side of the ideological spectrum. 2) It's when presenting your own ideas that your ideological positions are subject to scrutiny. This burden has been impossible to bear for the pacifist left. [2] What has been missed is that it's equally unbearable for the bloodthirsty right, because those calling for an all-out war on Islam and/or the Middle East are looking to create problems rather than solutions. They fail to make the most elementary distinctions between combatants and non-combatants, and are often guilty of romanticizing World War 3 - if not advocating it outright! To be perfectly clear: there is an ocean of difference between contemplating the stupidity of those Islamists who wish for Ragnarok, and being stupid enough to wish for it yourself. [1] Example: So all war is bad? So was WW2 bad? Wasn't it against the only real bad guys, those racist white men? Huh? [2] See footnote 1 directly above. |
10 questions for....
Parag Khanna James Flynn Jon Entine Gregory Clark György Buzsáki Heather Mac Donald Bruce Lahn A.W.F. Edwards Luigi Luca Cavalli-Sforza Joseph LeDoux Matthew Stewart Charles Murray James F. Crow Adam K. Webb Justin L. Barrett David Haig Judith Rich Harris Ken Miller Dan Sperber Warren Treadgold Armand M. Leroi John Derbyshire
Blogs
The GiveWell Blog Your Religion Is False Colby Cosh Steve Hsu Audacious Epigone Catallaxy Files Inductivist 2 Blowhards Genetic Future Agnostic Steve Sailer Dienekes Derek Lowe Razib Khan Razib at Comment is Free Secular Right Glenn Reynolds Jim Miller Kevin McGrew John Hawks Peter Fost Randall Parker Less Wrong Charles Murray Carl Zimmer EconLog Marginal Revolution
Principles of Population Genetics
Genetics of Populations Molecular Evolution Quantitative Genetics Evolutionary Quantitative Genetics Evolutionary Genetics Evolution Molecular Markers, Natural History, and Evolution The Genetics of Human Populations Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits Epistasis and Evolutionary Process Evolutionary Human Genetics Biometry Mathematical Models in Biology Speciation Evolutionary Genetics: Case Studies and Concepts Narrow Roads of Gene Land 1 Narrow Roads of Gene Land 2 Narrow Roads of Gene Land 3 Statistical Methods in Molecular Evolution The History and Geography of Human Genes Population Genetics and Microevolutionary Theory Population Genetics, Molecular Evolution, and the Neutral Theory Genetical Theory of Natural Selection Evolution and the Genetics of Populations Genetics and Origins of Species Tempo and Mode in Evolution Causes of Evolution Evolution The Great Human Diasporas Bones, Stones and Molecules Natural Selection and Social Theory Journey of Man Mapping Human History The Seven Daughters of Eve Evolution for Everyone Why Sex Matters Mother Nature Grooming, Gossip, and the Evolution of Language Genome R.A. Fisher, the Life of a Scientist Sewall Wright and Evolutionary Biology Origins of Theoretical Population Genetics A Reason for Everything The Ancestor's Tale Dragon Bone Hill Endless Forms Most Beautiful The Selfish Gene Adaptation and Natural Selection Nature via Nurture The Symbolic Species The Imitation Factor The Red Queen Out of Thin Air Mutants Evolutionary Dynamics The Origin of Species The Descent of Man Age of Abundance The Darwin Wars The Evolutionists The Creationists Of Moths and Men The Language Instinct How We Decide Predictably Irrational The Black Swan Fooled By Randomness Descartes' Baby Religion Explained In Gods We Trust Darwin's Cathedral A Theory of Religion The Meme Machine Synaptic Self The Mating Mind A Separate Creation The Number Sense The 10,000 Year Explosion The Math Gene Explaining Culture Origin and Evolution of Cultures Dawn of Human Culture The Origins of Virtue Prehistory of the Mind The Nurture Assumption The Moral Animal Born That Way No Two Alike Sociobiology Survival of the Prettiest The Blank Slate The g Factor The Origin Of The Mind Unto Others Defenders of the Truth The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition Before the Dawn Behavioral Genetics in the Postgenomic Era The Essential Difference Geography of Thought The Classical World The Fall of the Roman Empire The Fall of Rome History of Rome How Rome Fell The Making of a Christian Aristoracy The Rise of Western Christendom Keepers of the Keys of Heaven A History of the Byzantine State and Society Europe After Rome The Germanization of Early Medieval Christianity The Barbarian Conversion A History of Christianity God's War Infidels Fourth Crusade and the Sack of Constantinople The Sacred Chain Divided by the Faith Europe The Reformation Pursuit of Glory Albion's Seed 1848 Postwar From Plato to Nato China: A New History China in World History Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World Children of the Revolution When Baghdad Ruled the Muslim World The Great Arab Conquests After Tamerlane A History of Iran The Horse, the Wheel, and Language A World History Guns, Germs, and Steel The Human Web Plagues and Peoples 1491 A Concise Economic History of the World Power and Plenty A Splendid Exchange Contours of the World Economy 1-2030 AD Knowledge and the Wealth of Nations A Farewell to Alms The Ascent of Money The Great Divergence Clash of Extremes War and Peace and War Historical Dynamics The Age of Lincoln The Great Upheaval What Hath God Wrought Freedom Just Around the Corner Throes of Democracy Grand New Party A Beautiful Math When Genius Failed Catholicism and Freedom American Judaism Policies Terms of use © http://www.gnxp.com Razib's total feed: |