Sunday, July 16, 2006
numerical processing in whites and East Asians
Here is an interesting new paper in PNAS. You can read a news article about it here. Ten native Chinese speakers (of Chinese ethnicity) and ten native English speakers (white) were put through four different tasks while their brains were scanned by fMRI: (1) Symbol, deciding whether the third figure in a triplet of figural stimuli is presented in the same orientation as the previous two; (2) Number, same as Symbol except the stimuli are numbers rather than non-semantic figures; (3) Addition, deciding whether the third number is equal to the sum of the first two; and (4) Comparison, deciding whether the third number is larger than both of the first two. The control task consisted of deciding whether the third dot in a triplet of dots was the same color as the previous two. All subjects were comparable in age and of the same handedness. I would include here the slick figure summarizing the results, but Blogger is acting up again. I will have to settle for, uh, merely verbal representations (ha-ha).
While the Symbol condition evoked no differences of note between groups, significant differences emerged in the other three.
I am reminded of a passage from The Pleasure of Finding Things Out where Richard Feynman describes his informal experiments with counting silently in one's head. He found out that it is possible to count in two different ways: (1) Feynman himself seemed to say the numbers "one, two, three," and so on to himself, sotto voce as it were; while (2) his friend, the statistican John Tukey, visualized a mental number line and moved along it tick by tick. It has indeed been found in more recent studies that even "elementary" cognitive tasks can be represented in different ways (i.e., verbal-propositional v. spatial-pictorial) across individuals (e.g., Neubauer & Freudenthaler, 1994). So it seems that the present study has revealed another such difference scaled up to the level of group averages. The authors speculate that "the strong involvement of visuo-premotor association in NCS may be related to the experience of reading Chinese characters.... The use of the abacus in many Asian schools also suggests that, in one way or the other, the engagement of a 'mental image' for arithmetic could be related to the differences in brain activation." Well, maybe so. The logical next step then is to scan the brains of English speakers of Chinese ethnicity, preferably with both a larger sample and a larger control group. It should be possible to find Chinese Americans who do not read or speak Chinese. It is also desirable to ensure that the presents findings are not an artifact of an ability difference between the two groups. A pseudo-race group of white English speakers with an ability profile similar to that of typical East Asians (average or slightly above-average SAT-V scores, high SAT-M scores, high spatial scores) should be compared to a more typical group of whites; if differences in brain activation between whites and the pseudo-Asian group are similar to those in the present study, then the difference is not a true race- or culture-specific difference but rather a mere ability difference. In the latter case, of course, we would still want to know what causes the particular ability profile of East Asians in the first place. Can the extant literature give us any hints as to such a follow-up would turn out? Check out p. 169 of Nicholas Mackintosh's textbook IQ and Human Intelligence, which provides mean WISC-R subtest scores of the Japanese standardization sample. (The content of these subtests is described here.) The subtests can be classified as follows by performance of the Japanese relative to whites: much better than whites: Block Design better than whites: Arithmetic, Digit Span, Picture Completion, Picture Arrangement, Object Assembly comparable to whites: Similarities, Digit Symbol worse than whites: Information, Comprehension It is clear that Japanese children excel their white peers in mental tests that do not load on the verbal factor. This may be due to an advantage in g, but the Japanese-white gap on Block Design is so large that at this impressionistic level we are forced to also invoke a Japanese advantage in spatial-visualization ability. It is tempting to speculate that perhaps East Asians preferentially employ some form of analogical representation of numbers precisely because of this advantage. Regardless of its bearing on the processing of number, is the profile difference between whites and East Asians genetic or cultural? I know of one adoption study of East Asian mental abilities that has employed the WISC-R (Frydman & Lynn, 1989). After a correction for the Flynn Effect, it was found that 19 Korean orphans adopted into Belgian families between the ages of 3 to 72 months obtained an average IQ 10 points higher than the Belgian population mean (p < 0.01). Unfortunately, the subtest scores reported in this paper do not appear to be corrected for the Flynn Effect. I have listed the mean scores of these Korean adoptees in decreasing order: Block Design: 13.89 Picture Arrangement: 13.32 Object Assembly: 13.26 Picture Completion: 13.00 Similarities: 12.95 Arithmetic: 12.79 Coding: 12.58 Comprehension: 12.00 Information: 10.37 Vocabulary: 9.63 It is hard to say how much these average scores are shifted rightward of the whie means by the Flynn Effect. But the relative profile of these Korean children raised in Belgium is unmistakably similar to the profile of the native Japanese children. The nature of white-East Asian differences in mental abilities is complex and has not received nearly enough psychometric research effort as it deserves. But we have here evidence that the typical East Asian profile (high spatial, weak verbal) follows East Asian children regardless of the culture in which they are reared. Hmm. Something to chew on. |
10 questions for....
Parag Khanna James Flynn Jon Entine Gregory Clark György Buzsáki Heather Mac Donald Bruce Lahn A.W.F. Edwards Luigi Luca Cavalli-Sforza Joseph LeDoux Matthew Stewart Charles Murray James F. Crow Adam K. Webb Justin L. Barrett David Haig Judith Rich Harris Ken Miller Dan Sperber Warren Treadgold Armand M. Leroi John Derbyshire
Blogs
The GiveWell Blog Your Religion Is False Colby Cosh Steve Hsu Audacious Epigone Catallaxy Files Inductivist 2 Blowhards Genetic Future Agnostic Steve Sailer Dienekes Derek Lowe Razib Khan Razib at Comment is Free Secular Right Glenn Reynolds Jim Miller Kevin McGrew John Hawks Peter Fost Randall Parker Less Wrong Charles Murray Carl Zimmer EconLog Marginal Revolution
Principles of Population Genetics
Genetics of Populations Molecular Evolution Quantitative Genetics Evolutionary Quantitative Genetics Evolutionary Genetics Evolution Molecular Markers, Natural History, and Evolution The Genetics of Human Populations Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits Epistasis and Evolutionary Process Evolutionary Human Genetics Biometry Mathematical Models in Biology Speciation Evolutionary Genetics: Case Studies and Concepts Narrow Roads of Gene Land 1 Narrow Roads of Gene Land 2 Narrow Roads of Gene Land 3 Statistical Methods in Molecular Evolution The History and Geography of Human Genes Population Genetics and Microevolutionary Theory Population Genetics, Molecular Evolution, and the Neutral Theory Genetical Theory of Natural Selection Evolution and the Genetics of Populations Genetics and Origins of Species Tempo and Mode in Evolution Causes of Evolution Evolution The Great Human Diasporas Bones, Stones and Molecules Natural Selection and Social Theory Journey of Man Mapping Human History The Seven Daughters of Eve Evolution for Everyone Why Sex Matters Mother Nature Grooming, Gossip, and the Evolution of Language Genome R.A. Fisher, the Life of a Scientist Sewall Wright and Evolutionary Biology Origins of Theoretical Population Genetics A Reason for Everything The Ancestor's Tale Dragon Bone Hill Endless Forms Most Beautiful The Selfish Gene Adaptation and Natural Selection Nature via Nurture The Symbolic Species The Imitation Factor The Red Queen Out of Thin Air Mutants Evolutionary Dynamics The Origin of Species The Descent of Man Age of Abundance The Darwin Wars The Evolutionists The Creationists Of Moths and Men The Language Instinct How We Decide Predictably Irrational The Black Swan Fooled By Randomness Descartes' Baby Religion Explained In Gods We Trust Darwin's Cathedral A Theory of Religion The Meme Machine Synaptic Self The Mating Mind A Separate Creation The Number Sense The 10,000 Year Explosion The Math Gene Explaining Culture Origin and Evolution of Cultures Dawn of Human Culture The Origins of Virtue Prehistory of the Mind The Nurture Assumption The Moral Animal Born That Way No Two Alike Sociobiology Survival of the Prettiest The Blank Slate The g Factor The Origin Of The Mind Unto Others Defenders of the Truth The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition Before the Dawn Behavioral Genetics in the Postgenomic Era The Essential Difference Geography of Thought The Classical World The Fall of the Roman Empire The Fall of Rome History of Rome How Rome Fell The Making of a Christian Aristoracy The Rise of Western Christendom Keepers of the Keys of Heaven A History of the Byzantine State and Society Europe After Rome The Germanization of Early Medieval Christianity The Barbarian Conversion A History of Christianity God's War Infidels Fourth Crusade and the Sack of Constantinople The Sacred Chain Divided by the Faith Europe The Reformation Pursuit of Glory Albion's Seed 1848 Postwar From Plato to Nato China: A New History China in World History Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World Children of the Revolution When Baghdad Ruled the Muslim World The Great Arab Conquests After Tamerlane A History of Iran The Horse, the Wheel, and Language A World History Guns, Germs, and Steel The Human Web Plagues and Peoples 1491 A Concise Economic History of the World Power and Plenty A Splendid Exchange Contours of the World Economy 1-2030 AD Knowledge and the Wealth of Nations A Farewell to Alms The Ascent of Money The Great Divergence Clash of Extremes War and Peace and War Historical Dynamics The Age of Lincoln The Great Upheaval What Hath God Wrought Freedom Just Around the Corner Throes of Democracy Grand New Party A Beautiful Math When Genius Failed Catholicism and Freedom American Judaism ![]() ![]() Policies Terms of use © http://www.gnxp.com Razib's total feed: |